Moscow’s manipulation of statistics seen getting even worse in run-up to Putin’s re-election

Image: Alexander Petrosyan 

International, More

Russian officials have always manipulated and sometimes totally falsified statistical information about their country, but in the coming months as Vladimir Putin prepares for his re-election campaign, they are certain to do so even more than in the past to suggest the country as flourishing even if it is not, Sergey Shelin says.

The Rosbalt commentator says that plans to release statistics showing Russia and Putin in one as well are already part of the pre-election planning, now in full-swing given that the voting is only 18 months away and that such data are needed to counter “rumors” that things aren’t so good.

In sum, “the pre-election 2017 despite anything must become a year of economic and social victories, at least on paper.”

  1. Some of this will be achieved by changing the way certain statistics are calculated, as has happened in the last few weeks when GDP was “corrected” upward by changing the rules for its calculation.
  2. Another part will be achieved by changing the base lines against which the data are compared. If the situation in Russia looks bad compared to what it was in 2013, then Moscow statisticians will put out data comparing things to that in the crisis year of 2016 and say things are getting better and better.
  3. But a least some of this will reflect open falsification, especially if the Kremlin decides it needs to claim not a one percent growth rate but “three or even four” in order to win over those who think things are not going well, Shelin continues.

One place where all these methods may be employed together, the Rosbalt commentator says, is to allow Putin to claim that he has fulfilled his earlier promise to “catch up and surpass” Portugal in terms of GDP. By using “progressive methods,” Shelin says, that can be achieved “without any difficulty. It is only a matter of sleight of hand.”

The Kremlin’s statisticians will face a somewhat more difficult but not insuperable problem in presenting data “directly connected” with the lives of ordinary Russians such as housing, food prices, and wages and salaries. There people have their own experiences to rely on; they must be convinced that what they see with their own eyes is an exception.

These statistical magicians have the following tasks:

  • Their “minimum program is to forget about the miracles of 2015 but by any means to achieve some kind of growth in 2017 in comparison with the unsuccessful year of 2016.”
  • Their “maximum program” is to do even more by changing statistical methods and simply putting out inaccurate information.

They may take such steps regarding demography, given that births are falling. They can claim, somewhat plausibly, that there are more births than counted because many are out of wedlock, but one can be sure that if they come up with figures including those now, they will compare them only against figures from the past that didn’t include such children.

The statisticians are likely to make similar efforts with regard to Putin’s much-ballyhooed “May decrees.” While most think these were fulfilled because that is what the media say, statistics show that they haven’t been; and so the statistics will have to be brought into line with the Kremlin’s “truth” in order to help Putin win support.


Related:

 

Edited by: A. N.

Dear readers! Since you’ ve made it to this point, we have a favor to ask. Russia’s hybrid war against Ukraine is ongoing, but major news agencies have gone away, which is why it's extra important to provide news about Ukraine in English. We are a small independent journalist team on a shoestring budget, have no political or state affiliation, and depend on our readers to keep going (using the chanсe - a big thank you to our generous supporters, we couldn't make it without you.)  If you like what you see, please help keep us online with a donation

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Comments

  1. Avatar zorbatheturk says:

    Bring back the Soviet Five Year Plan. Then rig the numbers.

    1. Avatar Dagwood Bumstead says:

      As the French would say, “Plus ca change……….”

  2. Avatar Dagwood Bumstead says:

    Zounds! Dwarfstan, a country of some 140 million and huge mineral wealth actually manages to surpass Portugal’s GDP, a country with a population of only some 10.5 million which does not have Dwarfstan’s mineral wealth! What a miraculous performance by the demented pedophile dwarf and his team!!!!!!

    That Dwarfstan actually needs to falsify its statistics to “achieve” even this “performance” is truly pathetic.

    1. Avatar RedSquareMaidan says:

      No matter what magical numbers the Kremlinals come up with, the people won’t feel it, but will vote for the Killer because he has to run unopposed in order to win.

      1. Avatar Dagwood Bumstead says:

        Before 2014 Dwarfstan barely equalled Italy, a country with half Dwarfstan’s population and without the huge mineral wealth Dwarfstan has. The collapse of Dwarfstan’s chief souce of income, oil, gas and raw materials, plus sanctions, is ruining the country, best illustrated by the fact that Dwarfstan can’t even match Portugal’s economy now.

        How have the mighty fallen.

  3. Avatar Dirk Smith says:

    His days are numbered; the economy will collapse and ruSSia will lose the World Cup.

    1. Avatar Scradje says:

      Good. That will be proof that there is a God.

    2. Avatar Dagwood Bumstead says:

      Dwarfstan’s national football team won’t even survive the first round. Its “performance” at the last European Championship was dismal and there is no way that the team can improve to the level of, say, Brazil, Italy or Germany in 2 years- not even if the whole team is doped to the eyeballs (as it undoubtedly will be).

      1. Avatar Dirk Smith says:

        Their deal for the World Cup was a payola to corrupt Sepp Blatter; nothing more. Also, their end result for EuroCup16 was zero victories, two goals, one murder, and several assaults. Their stadiums are being built half-assed by the gay dwarf’s cronies. They’re not qualified to hold the World Cup. All smoke and mirrors; like Sochi was.

  4. Avatar Murf says:

    The first thing you have to remember about Russia at the
    Is period in time;
    There is no right.
    There is no wrong.
    There is only PUTIN.
    He is ALL.
    They are nothing.
    Their only purpose is to serve HIM.
    They only have value in so far as they are useful to HIM.
    Once you understand this underlying assumption,
    Everything they do makes sense.