Putin can’t ‘catch up and surpass West’ — he can only exploit divisions and spread chaos, Yakovenko says

Image: "Putinist Russia" by Saint Tepes via DeviantArt.com

Image: "Putinist Russia" by Saint Tepes via DeviantArt.com 

Analysis & Opinion, Politics, Russia

For more than 200 years, Russian leaders were inspired by the idea that their country could “catch up and surpass the West.” But now that it is clear that this is impossible under that country’s current regime, Vladimir Putin can only spread and exploit chaos abroad in the hopes of bringing the West down to its level, according to Igor Yakovenko.

Igor Yakovenko

Igor Yakovenko

The first Russian ruler to talk about “catching up” with the West was Peter the Great, but it soon became a dominant theme in Russian political discourse, the Moscow commentator says, with Soviet leaders routinely promising that they would achieve that goal eventually or even, in the case of Nikita Khrushchev, quite soon.

But the Soviet people reacted to his promises by joking that their country might catch up with the West but it must never “surpass” it lest the USSR’s backside become all too visible to everyone, Yakovenko recalls. Despite that, the old notion continued to inform Russian thinking during perestroika and after 1991.

There was one change, he continues. The second verb in the term was dropped, “and all liberal economists from Gaidar to Yavlinsky began to speak about the conception of catch up development.” And that was followed by a second, now long forgotten: Russians began to speak not about catching up but about “transit” — and defining it qualitatively not quantitatively.

Putin began his political ascent in December 1999 by pledging to “catch up and surpass” Portugal within 15 years, a much less ambitious program than before and one that Putin soon “lost interest in” and has not returned to as it has become clear how impossible meeting even that goal would be.

With the disappearance of even this limited goal, Putin has drawn on a comic-book notion of Eurasianism, one that reflects “the complete lack of his own positive program of development” and puts in its place “a broad negative [one]” at home and abroad. And that has resulted in “the inevitable shift” in his policies toward “the criminal.”

Putin, Yakovenko argues, “is sharply changing the rule of the game” so that he will be able to be the leader. Unable to play chess at a grandmaster level, he has in effect brought in a baseball bat to disorder things on the chessboard.

And the three most important of these “rule changes” are the following:

  • First, Putin has dispensed with the very notion of truth itself. He and his supporters love to talk about the world having moved into a “post-fact” stage, one in which Putin and his regime constantly lie to a point that is not only quantitatively different than that of other leaders who also lie on occasion but qualitatively too.

“All of Putin’s media are responsible for the destruction of truth regarding today; the Central Election Commission for the replacement of truth about the will of the people as expressed in elections; for lies in sport, Mutko and the FSB take the lead; for lies in foreign policy, the MFA, Lavrov, Zakharova, and Churkin.”

  • Second, Putin has done away with law inside the country and ignores international law abroad, opening the way for him to claim the right to say and do whatever he pleases against those who are weaker than he and to try to intimidate those who are still stronger into falling in line with him.
  • And third, he has made the exploitation of the divisions of others and the spread of chaos his chief goal. Lacking, in contrast to Soviet leaders, his own ideology or any serious plans for a future for other countries, the Putin regime has “chosen the tactic of the crocodile, lying at the bottom” and waiting for his victims to make a mistake.

Anywhere in the world where there are tensions and divisions, Putin’s appearance is “guaranteed.” He will do whatever it takes to exacerbate these tensions, sending in provocateurs, hacking computer systems, or threatening or actually using weapons. There is nothing he will not do to weaken others.

“To put Armenia and Azerbaijan at each other’s throats, to support the collapse of the European Union, to set the Russian-speaking population of the post-Soviet (and not only those!) against the local authorities, and to get involved in the Syrian conflict to drive it to a complete dead end” are all expressions of this tactic, Yakovenko says.

Today, in fact, “there is no one to equal Putin in mastering the use of provocations.” And “the generation of chaos, distrust and unfreedom is the main government business of Russia of the times of Vladimir Putin,” something for which world leaders were unprepared and still haven’t found a way to respond.

Unless they do, he concludes, Russia and the world face very dark days ahead.



Edited by: A. N.

Since you’re here – we have a favor to ask. Russia’s hybrid war against Ukraine is ongoing, but major news agencies have gone away. But we’re here to stay, and will keep on providing quality, independent, open-access information on Ukrainian reforms, Russia’s hybrid war, human rights violations, political prisoners, Ukrainian history, and more. We are a non-profit, don’t have any political sponsors, and never will. If you like what you see, please help keep us online with a donation!

Tags: , , , , , ,

  • laker48

    It’s what all KGB and GRU goons were train to do. Don”t expect a demolishing specialist to become a builder. Idiocy and cynicism of western politicians are limitless.

    • Dagwood Bumstead

      Some, such as Marine Le Pen and Gerhard Schröder, have been openly bought by the dwarf.

  • WisconsinUSA

    I hope and pray that The rest of the free world understands this. Thank you for a very profound article.

  • laker48

    One of new Secretary of Defence James “Mad Dog” Mattis’s memorable quotes: “Be polite, be professional, but have a plan to kill everybody you meet.”
    Don’t you think Trump may live by the same Gospel?

    • zorbatheturk

      I think Trump may have finally Peter Principled himself with his new gig.

      • laker48

        One thing is 100% sure; Trump is not a friend of either Putin or RuSSia. He means business and he is an extremely hard-nosed businessman. He won’t pass an opportunity to bankrupt RuSSia at no cost to the US and its allies.

        • Dagwood Bumstead

          It won’t take all that much to bankrupt Dwarfstan as it already is well on its way to bankruptcy thanks to the dwarf’s lunatic policies.

        • zorbatheturk

          Let’s hope so. Putin and China are constantly trying to undermine the US.

  • zorbatheturk

    The evil of the Putin is clearly visible. So ruSSia cannot even catch up to Portugal economically? With all its oil? Hard to believe. RuSSians must enjoy being losers… a psychoanalyst can probably explain it better.

    • Dagwood Bumstead

      Dwarfstan can’t pass Portugal because most of the $$$ brought in by oil and gas sales are pilfered by the dwarf and his crooked cronies. Much of what’s left is pilfered by their underlings; what remains is wasted on prestige projects and senseless wars Dwarfstan can’t win. All those wars do is burn money and cause thousands of dead Dwarfstanians.
      So, at the end of the day far too little is invested in Dwarfstan’s future- the end result is that it doesn’t have one.