This is how online hate-rhetoric mutates our values

Image: http://ethicaljournalismnetwork.org/

Image: http://ethicaljournalismnetwork.org/ 

Op-ed

Article by: Marta Barandiy and Anastasia Ariefieva

Emotions and ideas can easily be spread through social networks, unite people and create an “online crowd.” Those inside the crowd then behave the same way as in a real crowd, with all the ensuing consequences.

Facebook already has been proven to create an online “collective will,” which led to physical actions like demonstrations and revolutions. Yet before any actions take place, an emotional unification is created in the online space, which we suggest to call an “online-crowd.”

Online crowd

Crowds passionately defend their position, using aggressive claims and neglecting moral values.

Emotional identification with friends’ messages often results in their endorsement through likes, comments or shares, establishing an online crowd around a specific idea. It is similar to the classic crowd, containing an ideological unity, the sense of power, the sense of being attached to a certain community, lack of responsibility, mutual support of the members of the crowd, in particular, against those who oppose the original message. The classic anonymity is now being replaced by distant participation and transiency of information flow. Crowds passionately defend their position, using aggressive claims and neglecting moral values. Those criticizing the post fall victim to sarcasm and aggression of the participants of the “crowd.” The aim is to silence the opponent through depriving him of credibility and subsequently, audience.

Disinformation

Like mass media, social media tend to dramatize events and exaggerate the roles of those standing behind them. In addition, global communication has made it possible to spread lies across borders with impunity. The image politics that information war actors use parlays the emotionalism of entire nations.

Disinformation campaigns of different actors influence opinion leaders such as politicians, journalists, or celebrities, who may later spread false allegations. This may happen if they visit facebook groups or pages led by trolls, accept friend requests from trolls and get affected by them cognitively. Then, the opinion leaders play crucial roles in communicating disinformation to the wide population that can also be unethical in its wording.

In Dugin’s footsteps

Disinformation has been severely intensified by the use of dramatic fake pictures since 2014. A new era of propaganda introduced by trolls in their international “troll campaigns” signifies the clash of the authoritarian media of Putin’s Russia against libertarian media of European states. Authors of propagandist international blogs and fake news abuse the freedom of speech by targeting civilians who are not prepared to adequately react in the climate of information wars and who become vulnerable to manipulations.

People self-identify with the information disseminated by the trolls, which is beneficial for the Russian ruling elite. Namely, this falls into the Russian vision of the new world order, or rather world disorder. Moscow has worked on it since the 90’s. In his work The Foundation of Geopolitics, Alexandr Dugin, the far-right philosopher of Moscow’s foreign strategy, inspired Kremlin to pursue the goal of creating a “Russian World” and recommended a new military approach to achieve it. It includes creating a geopolitical disorder, spreading disinformation, and encouraging ethnic and racial conflicts abroad. European leaders of the modern far-right movement de-facto implement this strategy of Dugin by spreading hate and xenophobia.

Often, people who originally do not support far-right movements still use their rhetoric, thus distancing themselves from Europe’s liberal ideas and benefitting the Kremlin.

Mutation

Mutation of a person’s values happens due to the incorporation of external claims and views without full understanding what values stand behind them

Evil actions don’t appear out of thin air; rather, they are a result of a gradual change of the mindset and tolerance to what has earlier been unacceptable. The steadiness disrupts a person’s moral sensitivity, leading to a mutation of her values: by accepting the far-right rhetoric, people will justify this acceptance.

A person’s values mutate when external claims and views are incorporated without a full understanding of what values stand behind them. Being incorporated as a personal opinion, they leave the original values in the dark. Alternatively, original values may mutate by incorporating restrictions: “Everyone is equal (among white Europeans),” which will lead to double-standards, bringing allusions to Orwell’s Animal Farm.

Role of opinion leaders

Unfortunately, as shown above, in the age of free-circulating information and propaganda it is easy for ordinary people as well as opinion leaders to get trapped between multiple layers of manipulative emotional information pieces. Without knowing itthey become victims of the “online- crowd effect.”

Therefore, all those who shape opinions in our society must be aware  of the influence and contamination of hate rhetoric and disinformation. NGO-led awareness raising campaigns for media literacy should help achieve this goal.

Authors:Authors:

Marta Barandiy, PH.D. in International Law (Saarland University), the founder and chairwoman of the NGO Promote Ukraine, Brussels (www.promoteukraine.org)
Anastasia Ariefieva, Master of Philosophy (KU Leuven), internship in Promote Ukraine.

 

Edited by: Alya Shandra

  • zorbatheturk

    Kremtrolls are like playing whack-a-mole, as soon as one is identified and blocked a new one appears with another absurd fake moniker like ” Bob Belz ” and out spews another load of vicious lies and propaganda, leaning heavily on supposed ” Nazis ” and the evil west oppressing the majesty that is the ruSSian civilization while the word ” Putin ” seems to pepper the post like a crazy chef attempting a Sri Lankan curry.

    There are various ways of tackling the kremtroll menace, from flagging, blocking, ignoring, insulting, whikst trying to logically reason with them or pointing out the fallacy of their facts simply leads to another vicious post and being insulted and called vile names. These retards who troll for Putin are human scum, cybermaggots and oxygen thieves, true representatives of the evil fascist regime they work for. Unfortunately western media forums are now infested with these cockroaches. Someone needs to call an exterminator.

  • Eolone

    “…before any actions take place, an emotional unification is created in the online space”.

    Emotional unification predates the internet. It is largely a tactic of the right. Thomas Frank discusses it appearance in the US in “The Wrecking Crew”.

  • Alex George

    All true, but there is also the positive side – every time they try to spread their fake stories and fake photos, people appear to oppose them.

    By exposing the lies, often the end result on public opinion is the reverse of what the Russian propagandists hoped for.