The idea of a Shadow World Government has always been very popular among conspiracy theorists. Its manifestations might be different, but generally, the concept conjures up the image of a small group of men, deciding the fate of the world behind the scenes; puppet-masters, covertly controlling the world. Rulers of the rulers. EUvsDisinfo has described such cases frequently; here, for instance, or here.
The appeal of conspiracy theories is that they are virtually impossible to debunk. The premise on which they are based is the fact that everything is going on behind the scenes; behind veils, covertly, in the shadows, carried out by the world’s most powerful people with limitless resources. The complete absence of proof of the existence of the Shadow Rulers is actually the proof that they exist and that they are successful. We have encountered this logic in other cases as well. Any attempt to disprove the concept will be met with the counter-claim – “Yes, of course, you deny it; you are also part of it!” As the Shadow Government, the Deep State, by definition is covert, it must, logically, be malign. Why would they hide if they weren’t into something bad?
One of the most odious examples of the use of this concept for propaganda purposes is The Protocol of the Elders of Zion. Published in 1903 in Russia, the text describes a Jewish plan for global domination. The text has been proved to be a forgery made by the Tsarist Secret Police in Russia, but it is still distributed in anti-Semitic circles as a “proof” of a Jewish plot to rule the world.
The charm of the Shadow Government Theory is that it can be filled with anything you want. Catholics, bankers, Jews, Feminists, Free-Masons, “Big Pharma”, Muslims, the Gay Lobby, Bureaucrats… all depending on your target audience. You never need to prove anything and all the grievances of the audience can be explained – the Gay Lobby/Jews/Bureaucrats/Bankers have stolen our money, are developing germ weapons, instigating wars, installing presidents…
Further reading:
- Moscow TV revives infamous anti-Semitic forgery ‘Protocols of the Elders of Zion’
- EU Activities to Combat Anti-Semitism
- Komsomolskaya Pravda, Russia Today – leading outlets for anti-Semitic and anti-Israel propaganda
- Anti-Defamation League on “The Protocols of the Elders of Zion”
- New York Times sheds light on decades-old tradition of Kremlin disinformation campaign
- November Surprise: an Anti-Semitic Anniversary
- Anti-Semitism on the rise in Russia and Moscow sends the wrong message about this trend
- Antisemitism and pro-Kremlin propaganda
- ‘Beat the Jews, Save Russia’ – an ugly old slogan returns in Putin’s Russia
- Everyone against Russia
- Addressing the great “Jewish Communist” conspiracy
- Conspiracy: The US creates bioweapons in 400 countries (there are only 195)