“You Always Place Me Between Two Foreigners”
What just happened? Did Russian state media decide to drop disinformation and replace it with a democratic debate? Since when has the criticism of the authorities been allowed on prime-time Kremlin TV?
Click to watch the video below and see how the talk show host and other discussants giggle towards the end of the video when Leonid Gozman, a well-known opposition politician, openly criticizes the Kremlin and its media.
Judging from the reactions in the studio, Mr. Gozman could just as well have told a dirty joke or reminded the others of an embarrassing secret.
— Khodorkovsky Center (@mbk_center) December 3, 2018
Mr. Gozman can, in fact, be said to have reminded the audience of a secret: like the little boy in Hans Christian Andersen’s fairy tale, he breaks the spell of disinformation, points at the “emperor” – state propaganda – and reminds his fellow Russians that it is in fact “naked,” i.e. just an illusion:
“Once this show ends, everyone in the audience who has been ordered to clap, will come up to me and say, ‘actually, you’re right, we support what you say.’”
The aim is to show dissenters as disloyal citizens
But why this sudden deviation from the norm on state TV talk shows?
Leonid Gozman himself points out in the clip that the role of talk show propaganda is not necessarily to try to prove people wrong if they disagree with the official, Kremlin-approved line. Instead, the overarching aim is to discredit dissenters as disloyal citizens:
“Whenever I’m on your show, you always place me between two foreigners, to ‘show’ that I stand against Russia.”
Worth noting is also that not all dissenters are as lucky as Mr. Gozman when the only consequence he faces is smirking and giggling. Click here to watch examples of how e.g. foreign guests on Russian state TV talk shows have been interrupted, shouted at and even physically attacked live on air.
- The role of talk shows on pro-Kremlin TV
- Corruption and disinformation: Backstage at Russian television
- The trait of violence against foreigners on Russian TV
- Human rights defenders, Western diplomats attacked by Russian TV
- State TV in Russia as a weapon against the opposition
- “We don’t promote the English Queen’s anniversary!!!”
- Fake Western experts as a propaganda tool on Russian TV
- “To rule Russia, Putin doesn’t need mass murders: he has TV”
- “Russophobia” as a Russian propaganda tool
- Russian propaganda all too often promoted by ‘willing local participants,’ Imbi Paju says
- Political censorship in Russian comedy shows
- Top Russian state TV propagandists pick up this year’s Russian “Emmy Awards”
- Russian TV is not about Russia: Ukraine, US, EU get six times more attention in last week’s most watched shows
- Study: A third of Moscow TV news is about Ukraine, and 90% of it is negative