Last week, a five-year-old Russian propaganda fake narrative about legalizing incest in Europe emerged once again. Among other week’s disinformation cases, there are Russia’s foreign minister stating that Russia has not violated the Budapest Memorandum, Euronews telling that the international sanctions against Russia were illegal, and even a fake Ukrainian policeman publishing a photo of himself clad in Nazi uniform. Editor’s Note
Almost five years ago on 18 August 2013, a video in Russian named “Horror. Legalization of incest in Europe” was published on YouTube.
It is a story that indeed resembles a horror movie: slowly, it tells us with a threatening voice, European countries and especially Scandinavia, are moving towards legalizing incest and making even “incestophobia” punishable.
In fact, incest is prohibited in the EU countries.
Now, the video has been shared over 8 600 times on Facebook. It got a whole new life and audience for its disinforming messages when it was posted on Facebook in November last year, and the fact that many commentators see it as a propagandistic piece doesn’t prevent others from sharing it.
The story is scraped together from screenshots of articles with headlines that actually tell the opposite of the disinformation claims – like “Icelandic app aims to prevent incest” – or video footage from police cracking down protests that have no connection whatsoever with the topic.
Delivering a warning
The video stuns viewers with twisted figures like “38 500 children that have been taken against their will and handed over to same-sex families in Germany.” We have seen before how exactly the same disinformation message made its way to Georgia. And this is not surprising: if the Youtube video is the oldest version of the story, the message has been online for almost five years, which is more than enough for a disinformation message to put down roots. The message is clear: warning that following the path of supporting democratic values will inevitably lead to moral decay and catastrophe. And it is one of the favorites of the pro-Kremlin disinformation campaign.
But if effectively debunked, attempts to use social media to disinform the public can have a much shorter life cycle. This week, the Dnipropetrovsk police department in Ukraine refuted the disinformation that a Ukrainian policeman published a Facebook profile photo with a Nazi uniform. In fact, the person has never worked in the police.
Distorting international law
The complexity of international law makes it one of the easiest sources to create pro-Kremlin disinformation. So this week Russia’s foreign minister was reported stating that Russia has not violated the Budapest Memorandum. Argumentation: Russia has neither used nor threatened to use nuclear weapons against Ukraine.
Sounds convincing? Actually, the Budapest Memorandum states that “The United States of America, the Russian Federation, and the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, reaffirm their commitment to Ukraine, in accordance with the principles of the CSCE [Commission on Security and Cooperation in Europe] Final Act, to respect the Independence and Sovereignty and the existing borders of Ukraine” – which Russiaclearly has violated by annexation of Crimea.
Secondly, Russia’s president has already confirmed that Russia was ready to put its nuclear weapons into a state of combat readiness during tensions over the crisis in Ukraine and Crimea.
Even Western outlets may end up confusing the audience with reports on Crimea. This week, a Euronews article told how the Russian army trains children in Crimea on how to plant and defuse landmines as part of army’s “recruitment drive.” The article failed to explain the background of Russia’s illegal annexation of Crimea, or to tell that Russia supports separatists in the war in Ukraine. Though the version of the article now on the website does concede that “Crimea, seen as a geopolitical stronghold for Moscow, was annexed from Ukraine in 2014” it also described how the European Union and the US were prompted to impose “sanctions against Russia over the “illegal” move.” We recall that The United Nations General Assembly Resolution clearly says that Russia’s actions in the peninsula, as well as the referendum held in the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, violate international law.
Disinformation cases reported in the previous week:
- The Anglo-Saxons rule America “from abroad” and are now trying to control Russia
- Crimean Tatars to support Putin in March Presidential election
- The US becomes the world center of neo-Nazism and anti-Semitism
- 50 thousand people would have got killed in Donbas if Russia did not intervene in Ukraine in 2014
- By calling Moscow an “aggressor,” destroying Russian people and letting foreign armed forces into Ukraine, Kyiv has violated the Treaty of Friendship and Cooperation with Russia
- Putin turns out to be the most popular politician on the Latvian TV in 2017
- George Soros wants another change of government in Ukraine
- The US organizes migration to destroy Europe
- In terms of trade, Russia is ten times more important for the Czech Republic than France
- Ukrainian Orthodox Church of the Kyivan Patriarchate does not exist
- Kyiv residents want Russian social media platforms back
- Drug liberalization in Georgia ordered by Soros
- Ukrainian policeman published a Facebook profile photo with a Nazi uniform
- The white slaves – migrants rape British girls for years, police fears accusations of racism
- Lithuania introduces unilateral tariffs on railway cargo
- Economies of the Baltic countries can’t make progress in the EU
- Russia did not violate the Budapest Memorandum
- Censorship in the Baltic states
- The Baltic countries are driving the EU’s EaP policies with one single aim – to weaken Moscow
- All three Baltic states are disappearing
- Slowly, incest is being legalized in Europe
- Russian army enthuses kids about de-mining and defusing bombs
- Breaking the rules: Crimea, disinformation, doping
- Revisionism, misinterpreted facts, video game image as evidence
- Seven things you should know about pro-Kremlin disinformation
- The main disinformation target of the last week: Ukraine’s proposal for the UN peacekeeping mission
- Corruption and disinformation: Backstage at Russian TV
- Latest disinformation narratives: Get ready for pro-Kremlin tinnitus
- Democracies should prepare for the long fight against Russian disinformation warfare: study
- Disinformation across ages: Russia’s old but effective weapon of influence
- “Poisoning” by headlines: how Russian disinformation keeps spreading