Putin’s power isn’t legal but has been legitimized by violence and lies, Yakovenko says

Soldiers of the National Guard of Russia (aka Russian Guard), a 500,000-strong internal security structure subordinated to Putin personally

Soldiers of the National Guard of Russia (aka Russian Guard), a 500,000-strong internal security structure subordinated to Putin personally 

International, More

Vladimir Putin’s power is “not legal because he was not once chosen in correspondence with the law,” but it is “legitimate” because “the majority” of those people under his control recognize it as such since they know that they have little chance to change it, Igor Yakovenko says.

Like criminal groups who took over portions of Russia at various points in the last two decades, Putin “came to power over the corpses of blown up apartment blocks, the deaths of hostages at Beslan,” and then” as his power grew, via the oppression of “tens and hundreds of thousands in Ukraine and Syria.”

The legitimacy Putin now enjoys has “nothing in common with the classical types of legitimacy described by Max Weber,” the Russian commentator says. It is not of the traditional kind because Putin is too cowardly to restore the tsarist system. It is not charismatic because only the most naïve could see him as an outstanding personality.

And it is not legitimacy conferred by democratic, legal or rational arrangements. Indeed, Yakovenko argues,

“the fake character of elections has transformed the power in Russia into something illegal and makes the legal type of legitimation impossible.” But his power is legitimate because the population puts up with it and isn’t prepared to challenge it.

“The basic source of Putin’s legitimacy and that of his power is total state force and total state lies.” The forms of the former are varied and selective, and he forms of the latter are “unprecedented in history.” Together, they give Putin the kind of legitimacy that the Stockholm syndrome gives a hostage taker among his hostages.

According to Yakovenko, “this type of legitimacy in Russian history has predominated more than two hundred years,” and its current hyperbolic form has an important consequence: “Power is becoming in principle alien,” just as that of criminal bosses are alien to the smaller groups of people they oppress.

There is a myth that Yeltsin was weak and that Putin is strong. In reality, both the one and the other were weak, the commentator says. “But by his personal qualities, Yeltsin was an immeasurably stronger leader than Putin.” Unlike his successor, he wasn’t afraid of competitors or strong regional leaders.

Under Yeltsin but not under Putin, Russia could justifiably be called “a federation.” And for a time, it almost ceased to be an empire.” But that time has passed. Putin because of his cowardliness and weakness cannot bear anyone in the country to have “the slightest signs of their own legitimacy.” He alone must have that quality, however it has been achieved.

Such an arrangement is inherently unstable, Yakovenko says, but it is a mistake to predict where and when everything will come apart. It could start in the North Caucasus and especially in Daghestan or it could come from “any region” such as Siberia, the Urals, or even Moscow and St. Petersburg” whose interests Putin has denigrated just as much.

But one thing is clear, the commentator says, and it is this:

“the longer this regime holds on, the greater is the possibility that is fall will lead to the disintegration of Russia into independent states” and at the same time “the less likely it becomes that these independent states will again have the chance to come together into some kind of confederation or federation.”

The reason for that is that “with each year the Putin regime lasts, the degradation of legal institutions and the alienation of people from the power grows; and this means that the base of the post-Putin independent states could become precisely regional [criminal groups]” who will maintain themselves by force and lies and by displaying hatred to the idea of Russia as a whole.


Edited by: A. N.

Dear readers! Since you’ ve made it to this point, we have a favor to ask. Russia’s hybrid war against Ukraine is ongoing, but major news agencies have gone away, which is why it's extra important to provide news about Ukraine in English. We are a small independent journalist team on a shoestring budget, have no political or state affiliation, and depend on our readers to keep going (using ťhe chance - a big thank you to our generous supporters, we couldn't make it without you). We are now $5,000 short of our financial goal and need your support to continue working. If you like what you see, please help keep us online with a donation!

Tags: , , , , , ,


  1. Avatar veth says:

    Russian Su-24 warplane crashes at air base in Syria, crew dies – media A Russian Su-24 frontline bomber rolled off the runway on takeoff from Russia’s Hmeymim air base in Syria on Tuesday, Russian news agencies cited Russia’s defense ministry as saying, adding that the warplane’s crew died in the accident, as reported by Reuters. World 11:52, 10 October 2017
    The crew, bound for a combat mission, failed to eject themselves from the aircraft. Warplanes of this type carry a crew of two pilots, according to Reuters. According to reports from the scene, a technical fault was believed to be behind the accident, the defense ministry was cited as saying.

    Read more on UNIAN: https://www.unian.info/world/2179699-russian-su-24-warplane-crashes-at-air-base-in-syria-crew-dies-media.html

  2. Avatar Ihor Dawydiak says:

    “Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely”. That is why Putin and his “putinistas” are condemned to the trash heap of history.

      1. Avatar Screwdriver says:

        Ukraine teens arrested in vandalism at Jewish cemetery

        Read more on UNIAN: https://www.unian.info/society/2180221-ukraine-teens-arrested-in-vandalism-at-jewish-cemetery-media.html

        1. Avatar zorbatheturk says:

          Bogovsky. Float away.

    1. Avatar RedSquareMaidan says:

      Putin has turned Russia into a mafia syndicate. Post-Putin each region will want their own power and Russia will eat itself. Time for Ukraine to start requiring visas from the mafia.

      1. Avatar Czech Mate says:

        their future really does look bleak and bleaker still. If they go wild after the tzar is gone then chances are the proletariat will be looking to find a new tyrant who will bring “order” in no time. Vicious spiral.

    2. Avatar Dale Davies says:

      Trash heap of history may be correct. However there will be entities in the ashes that will erect statues of the fearless Pootin that held the great USA at bay. Naturally those staues will be 6 or 7 feet tall.

      1. Avatar Czech Mate says:

        Maybe those multiple size Putinoshkas like matryoshkas.

  3. Avatar veth says:

    Turkey’s leading defense company Aselsan has signed a $43.6 million contract to supply communications systems to Ukraine, the firm said on Oct. 10.

  4. Avatar veth says:

    Ukraine’s defense ministry plans to considerably increase funding for modernization and purchase of new combat vehicles. Defense minister Stepan Poltorak posted this on Facebook.

    ‘When the International arms exhibition in Kyiv is over (it kicked off on Tuesday, October 10, – 112 International), we’re going to sign the deal on buying BTR-4E’s of the latest modification. This year, we submitted amendments to the state defense order, and we’re going to significantly increase the order for Stugna and Corsair anti-tank missile launchers,’ Poltorak wrote.

    He added that thanks to the allocations that the ministry was granted this summer, the defense industry continues to sign documents for construction of Oplot tanks; the construction is now underway.

  5. Avatar veth says:

    Ukravtodor plans to build Ukraine-Hungary highway
    A new road will connect Lviv and Budapest

    14:52, 10 October 2017

    112 Agency
    The State Agency of Auto-Roads of Ukraine (Ukravtodor) claimed about the intention to build a highway Lviv-Budapest through the checkpoint ‘Dijda’. The press service of Ukravtodor reported this.

    Ukravtodor and the World Bank began the preparation (pre-feasibility study) of the building project of the first-class road Lviv-Mukachevo within the implementation of this project.

    ‘This highway will become the main arterial road of the export of the Ukrainian goods to the Eastern and Southern Europe and a transit corridor of the international trade through Ukraine from Belarus and Baltic countries to the countries of the Eastern and Southern Europe and it also will provide the stable connection of Zakarpattia with other regions of Ukraine’, the message said.

    Ukravtodor noted that the road M-06 Lviv-Mukachevo lies at the complex mountain relief and it takes about 3.5 hours to pass it. A new road should shorten the way time to two hours. The highway will connect Lviv with the Hungarian highway M-3 Budapest-Nyiregyhaza and it will become the main motor corridor between Ukraine and Hungary.

    Earlier, Minister of Transport and Infrastructure Volodymyr Omelyan claimed that the building of the toll roads can begin in 2018 in Ukraine.

  6. Avatar svend says:

    I dont thin it will matter who take over Russia after Putler. Becaurse if Putler with friends continued to destroy Russia, there will be nothing left.

  7. Avatar svend says:

    GOOD NEWS in Prava. Putler has promised to kill Russians if Russia will not be a member of European Court of Human Right next year. But I see a problem for Russians. Putler dont know what Human Right is, so Russia cant be a member, ergo more dead Russians.

    1. Avatar veth says:

      This list will help: List of dead Russians soldiers in Donbass…………….


  8. Avatar zorbatheturk says:

    RuSSia must go the way of Jugoslavia.