HOLODOMOR 1933: Light a candle in your window


History, International, Ukraine

James E. Mace (February 18, 1952 – May 3, 2004) was an American historian, professor, and researcher of the Holodomor. In 1982, at an international conference on the Holocaust and genocide Mace stated: “In order to centralize the power in the hands of Stalin, what was needed was to destroy the Ukrainian peasant, the Ukrainian intellectuals, the Ukrainian language, Ukrainian understanding of their history and to destroy Ukraine as such. This was simply calculated and primitive: No people, as a result no country, and the result – no problem.”

Professor Mace wrote the following article for DEN newspaper on February 18, 20013:

I was allotted five minutes to explain the famine of 1933 in Ukraine before the American Commission on Holodomor. There was clearly not enough time to say much, except that we had done everything we could. Ukraine, with a few exceptions such as Communist leader Petro Symonenko, generally reached the same conclusion, namely that Ukrainians had been victims of genocide in the 1930s, and were psychologically so mutilated and scarred that many weaknesses and failures of the Ukrainian government can be explained by these horrifying years.

As a foreigner, I don’t feel very comfortable giving political advice… even when I hear some Communists shouting that I should go back to my Indians. However, I’ve learned one thing during the years spent studying this tragedy, although I’m not sure that it’s correctly understood. As a person who’s tried vainly to establish an institute for the study of genocide ten years ago, I truly welcome the recent initiative of some Ukrainian politicians who created the Institute for the Study of the Holodomor.

I also commend Communist deputy Borys Oliynyk who recently called for a public declaration of all the perpetrators and victims (which is easier said than done!), and I fully support the project for a monument to the victims of Holodomor, largely overdue, in my opinion.

Finally, I would also like to suggest an action of national memory that could be observed by everyone: on the national day of remembrance commemorating the victims of 1933 (the fourth Saturday in November), given that every Ukrainian, almost every family lost a loved one, I would ask everyone to light a candle in memory of the dead. It would be a fitting response to Oleksandr Bykovets, a priest in America, when he pondered over the suffering endured by Ukraine over the years:

 “… All were willing to sacrifice themselves; they knew that they’d be destroyed today or tomorrow, but they were concerned about one thing – Will the world know about it?… And the second question, more spiritual – Will anyone pray for all who perished?”

Even seven decades later, a candle that flickers in the window seems to be a worthy answer!

Holodomor memorial. The Holodomor/????????? was a man-made famine in the Ukrainian SSR between 1932 and 1933. During the famine, 2.4 - 7.5 millions of Ukrainians died of starvation.

Holodomor Memorial in Kyiv




Translated by: Christine Chraibi

Source: DEN

Dear readers! Since you’ ve made it to this point, we have a favor to ask. Russia’s hybrid war against Ukraine is ongoing, but major news agencies have gone away, which is why it's extra important to provide news about Ukraine in English. We are a small independent journalist team on a shoestring budget, have no political or state affiliation, and depend on our readers to keep going (using the chanсe - a big thank you to our generous supporters, we couldn't make it without you.)  If you like what you see, please help keep us online with a donation

Tags: , , , , , , ,


  1. Avatar Mykola Banderachuk says:

    the guilty have never been brought to justice, their children deny the Holodomor ever happened. Shame

    1. Avatar Turtler says:

      Their justice is not of this world.. .but it exists.

      And itheir statues and stature are being brought low as we speak.

  2. Avatar Randolph Carter says:

    Please know, little one, that as much as there are evil people in the world, there are also those who stand against them and never surrender. Such innocents as you will live forever in honored memory and the horror you endured will never be forgotten.

  3. Avatar Turtler says:

    One of the great undertold crimes in history. My heart goes out to those never saw the day this would be shown to the world, and those fighting for it.

    It is small condolensce, but just take comfort in how your latter day successors are fighting well for a free Ukraine, and an acolyte of Stalin’s has gone to hell.

  4. Avatar Turtler says:

    Support for the Stalin Terror Gulag was always a minority in the West, though ti was a vocal minority that did everything it could to defend them. Like the New York Times.

    But the truth is the West was doing what it could to provide food aid. It just was

    “Know the facts of USA pies dents hoover — Roosevelt FDR. And us
    anglo. Backing of communists USSR. from Lenin to Stalin ”

    MOFO< do you even realize that the US, Britain, and other Western Allies fought a WAR with the Soviets during Lenin's era? In places like Murmansk and Siberia and the Baltis? and that they supported the independent nations of Eastern Europe in defeating the Soviets like at the Battle of Warsaw?

    Or how Stalin made alliances with Hitler SPECIFICALLY to do an end run around the West and was planning to launch a third world war against them when they died?

    "behind the Plans for Industry and Collectivist ion of Agriculture. "

    This is true, US industry did play a sickening and prominant role in building Stalin's infrastructure.

    But it was mainly PRIVATE initiatives, not government ones. And for that matter several of those (like the much-maligned Koch Senior) got back and realized what a monster they helped.