At a time when many commentators are seeking to explain what is going on in Ukraine by searching for analogies with other places and events, it is useful to be reminded of the limits of at least some of these comparisons as Bohdan Butkevych does in an article entitled “10 Reasons Why the Donbas will Not Become Ulster.”
The “Fourth Power” analyst points out that “journalists and publicists, especially those who are pro-Russian, love to draw parallels between the war in the Donbas and the conflict in Ulster, thereby attempting to show that the war in Ukraine is a civil war,” but there is no factual basis for such claims.
The civil conflict in Northern Ireland lasted “more than 40 years” while the one in the Donbas was provoked by Moscow and is now directly supported by its troops, turning what the Russian side liked to claim was a “hybrid” conflict into “an ordinary war of conquest,” according to Butkevich.
That is obvious if one makes a serious comparison of the two, and he offers ten ways in which the two are very different:
- The History of the Question.
- The conflict in Northern Ireland has its roots in the English conquest of Ireland in the 12th century and the subsequent colonization of the northern countries by British people, almost all of whom were Protestants.
- The war in the Donbas is totally dissimilar. Until the mid-19th century, “this territory was practically empty.” It acquired importance because of industrial development, something that attracted people from throughout the Russian Empire and USSR regardless of ethnicity and who were mixed together once they got there. Indeed, the term “Donbas” is “more an economic than a political one,” let alone “a cultural or ethnic” description.
- The Causes of the Conflict.
- The struggle in Northern Ireland was between Catholics who wanted to join the Republic of Ireland and the Protestants who “by manipulating the law and using the support of London” were able to prevent that. The Catholics turned to terrorist actions, and the Protestants both responded directly and forced London to send troops to try to suppress the rising.
- The Donbas was and is different. A privileged economic zone in Soviet times, it has suffered economically since then. The oligarchs in the region and the pro-Moscow Party of the Regions used it to try to retain power in Kyiv. When that didn’t work, Moscow intervened.
- The Typology of the Conflict.
- “The conflict in Ulster is a civil war with internal causes and a logic of development,” Butkevich says.
- “The war in the Donbas is in essence an invasion by Russian under the form of inciting a civil conflict.” But it is not a civil conflict in the sense that the one in Ulster is.
- The Mentality of the Population.
- “Irish Catholic, Protestant Englishmen and Protestant Irishmen are a settled population in Ulster.” Their views have been fixed by centuries of historical experience; they are not subject to radical and rapid change.
- The majority of the people of the Donbas have been there no more than two or three generations; they are typical of “new arrivals” in that they have not formed specific “traditions, views and worldviews” and are more subject to the influence of propaganda.
- The Religious Issue.
- The divide between Catholics and Protestants forms the basis for the divisions in Northern Ireland.
- There is no such divide in the Donbas, despite efforts by Russian propagandists to spark one.
- The Nationality Question.
- In Ulster, this is the key division.
- In the Donbas, it isn’t. Ukrainians and Russians “are fighting on both sides,” and “the chief role in the conflict is played not by nationality but by worldview factors,” with those supporting a liberal democratic order being for Ukraine and those supporting “national conservatism” backing Russia.
- Foreign Interference.
- Although the IRA received some support from abroad, “the conflict was entirely internal.
- But in the Donbas, “from the very beginning, Russia took the most immediate part in exacerbating it” and finally “introduced regular units of the Russian army,” making the conflict into an ordinary war of conquest.
- Type of Military Actions.
- Weapons and Tactics.
- In Ulster, the basic weapons were personal arms and explosive used to carry out terrorist attacks.
- In the Donbas, the main weapons are heavy artillery and tanks used to carry out aggression or defense against it.
- The Number of Victims.
- Over almost 40 years of conflict in Northern Ireland, an estimated 3,000 to 8,000 people were killed or less than 250 per year on average at most.
- In the Donbas, the number of killed is more than 5,000 and may be as much as 10,000 – and that in one year, not 40.