Separatism Transcarpathian style: is Hungary aiming to grab a part of Ukraine?

A parade involving the Hungarian minority in Ukraine. Photo: zakarpattya.net.ua

A parade involving the Hungarian minority in Ukraine. Photo: zakarpattya.net.ua 

Politics

Ukrainian-Hungarian tensions show no sign of dying down. On 13 October, despite protests of the Ukrainian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, a “self-determination for Zakarpattia” rally was held in Budapest, the participants of which proclaimed that the western-lying Oblast of Ukraine belongs to Hungary. Weeks earlier, the Ukrainian Security Service detained a gang with reportedly Russian connections planning to bolster ethnic tensions by blowing up Hungarian monuments in Zakarpattia, a region with a large Hungarian minority. This all is happening on the backdrop of Hungary’s sharp protest to Ukraine’s new education law limiting the scopes of using minority languages in education – Hungary had demanded the EU review the Association Agreement it had recently ratified with Ukraine. Ukrainians accuse Hungary of imperial ambitions, and Russia of fostering Hungarian separatism as part of its hybrid war against Ukraine. Here is a roundup of what Ukrainian experts and journalists are saying about the problem.
Serhiy Halchenko, TSN

Some Hungarian politicians dream of reconstructing the country’s pre-WWII borders. This means incorporating the borderline areas of Austria, nearly one half of Slovakia, a large part of the Ukrainian Zakarpattia Oblast (also known as Transcarpathia), a part of Romania, Serbia, Croatia, and the frontier of Slovenia into Hungaria.

Anno1938

When in 2011 Hungary took up the presidency in the EU, Hungarian officials presented this historical map. Despite the scandal that this caused in the EU, Hungarian politicians haven’t given up on the idea, which is much to the Kremlin’s liking. What should Ukraine expect from Hungary and are fears of Hungarian separatism in its westernmost Zakarpattia Oblast grounded in reality?

The phantom of a Great Hungary

The largest ethnic Hungarian village in Ukraine’s Zakarpattia Oblast, which borders Hungary, is Velyka Dobron. Over 5,500 ethnic Hungarians live there today. In Velyka Dobron all the signs are written in Hungarian and Ukrainian, from street signs to advertising. There are dozens of villages like this along the Ukrainian-Hungarian border. They are in fact culturally autonomous villages. Almost 150,000 ethnic Hungarians live in these villages. Overall, 12% of the population in Zakarpattia Oblast identify as Hungarians. Government officials from Hungary often drop in with visits. The Hungarian government officially provides interest-free loans and grants to the Hungarian speaking residents of Zakarpattia to win their loyalty. This is a new strategy. All the countries bordering Hungary are wary of this subtle game Budapest is playing. The name of this game is Greater Hungary.

Hungarian_language3

The Hungarian minority in Ukraine lives in a compact zone along the Hungarian border

In recent years, official Budapest has been pursuing a policy of providing the residents of Transcarpathia with generous funds for development, along with an active promotion of autonomy for the region. Are these processes connected? And do the ethnic Hungarians really want to separate from Ukraine? Or is this just another example of the same old Kremlin strategy: divide and conquer – insert discord between Kyiv and Budapest; stir up ethnic enmity between Ukrainians and Hungarians.

old-hungaryIn 1920, at the end of World War I, Hungary was a signatory to the Treaty of Trianon to formally end the war between most of the allies and the Kingdom of Hungary. It regulated the status of an independent Hungarian state and defined its borders. The country lost two-thirds of its territories, including a small part of Ukraine’s modern Zakarpattia Oblast, where some 150,000 Hungarians still live nowadays.

After Viktor Orban became the Prime Minister of Hungary in 2014, government officials in Hungary began to state publicly that the ethnic Hungarians who currently live in Romania, Slovakia, Serbia, and Ukraine deserve autonomy. The Prime Minister himself made similar statements.

“The ethnic Hungarians who live in the Transcarpathia region should be granted dual citizenship and official autonomy,” the Hungarian Prime Minister said. When the Ukrainian Ministry of Foreign Affairs summoned the Hungarian ambassador to file a complaint against the Prime Minister, the ambassador claimed that Orban’s statement had been misinterpreted.

Serhiy Fedak, a professor at the Uzhgorod National University, located in the Oblast center of Zakarpattia Oblast, told that Hungary is promoting its foreign policy interests in Ukraine, but these actions are incomparable to Russia’s actions in the East, naming a recent attempt to set up agitation road signs in the Berehiv and Vynohradiv districts which stated that this is a territory of Hungarian language and that Hungary starts from this place. He considers such agitation as unacceptable. [Ed: the signs were removed and the two Ukrainians are now under trial, being accused of undermining Ukraine’s sovereignty.]

Velyka Dobron village next to Uzhgorod is mostly populated by Hungarians. Despite this, the Head of the village council is Ivan Popka, a Ukrainian. The village lives at the expense of agriculture. The greenhouses where the vegetables are grown were built with grant money the Hungarian government has made available to all the places where ethnic Hungarians reside. Last year Hungary has been providing financial support to the ethnic Hungarians in all the countries that have a border with Hungary.

According to Ivan Popka, Hungary is doing this to keep the ethnic Hungarians in place, in Transcarpathia, to prevent them from going off somewhere else to work. He says there are no territorial claims.

Officially, Hungary is not pursuing a policy of separatism. There is no proof, in the press, or in conversations, that the government of Hungary is seeking to reclaim the territories it once had. It is the far-right Jobbik party in Hungary, which has close ties to the Kremlin that has claims to foreign territory.

As political analyst Dmytro Tuzhanskyi wrote in Yevropeiska Pravda, this party is responsible for holding a “self-determination for Zakarpattia” rally in Budapest on 13 October. Jobbik conducted a similar meeting on 27 March 2014, days after the Russian annexation of Crimea. The initiator of both rallies is the same, Tomas Gaudi-Nagy. In April 2014, he spoke at a PACE session wearing a Tshirt with the inscription “Crimea legally belongs to Russia, Transcarpathia legally belongs to Hungary.” Jobbik never hid its close relationship and collaboration with Russia. Its members were observers at the pseudoreferendum in Crimea.

 

Photo: Liubov Nepop, Ambassador of Ukraine to Hungary

Participant at the rally in Budapest on 13 October 2017 wears a Tshirt with separatist slogans. Photo: Liubov Nepop, Ambassador of Ukraine to Hungary

The government, however, is trying to distance itself from Jobbik’s statements, continues Serhiy Halchenko at TSN. The official line of the government is that their intent is to keep the ethnic Hungarians close to Hungary by providing financial support. Kalman Hodor owns a business in Velyka Dobron. This year he received UAH ($7,500) to build greenhouses. One of the conditions under which Hungary provides the assistance is that Kalman must remain where he is for at least the next five years.

Cultural autonomy with dual citizenship

According to Ukrainian political analyst Dmytro Tuzhanskyi,

“Official Hungary promotes an internal autonomy for Hungarians in Ukraine, but it’s important to stress that this is not a territorial autonomy. The Hungarian government insists that Hungarians abroad must insist on a political, cultural autonomy, not a territorial one. At least, for now.”

In addition to providing financial support, he says, Hungary has introduced a policy of dual citizenship for ethnic Hungarians living outside of Hungary. A Hungarian passport could be obtained in practically any village office in the ethnic Hungarian villages in Zakarpattia. Presently Budapest is working hard at persuading Ukrainian officials to permit the ethnic Hungarians of Zakarpattia to have a Hungarian passport.

“Hungary had tried to to implement the same policy in Slovakia and Romania. The governments of these countries responded differently. For instance, Slovakia not only prohibited dual citizenship but also applied a prohibitive fine as a penalty as well,” the political analyst explained.

hungary2

The borders of interwar Hungary are outlined in red. The percent of the Hungarian minority in the population of each country is in red.

Since 2012, thousands of Hungarians of Zakarpattia received a Hungarian passport while being citizens of Ukraine. Among them are ethnic Hungarians who occupy official government positions. In obtaining a Hungarian passport they swear allegiance to Hungary. It’s difficult telling in whose interests they are now working.

It seems the official policy of Hungary towards Transcarpathia is three-pronged:

  1. providing financial support to ethnic Hungarians for cultural and educational development;
  2. promoting the right to dual citizenship;
  3. supporting the ethnic Hungarians who seek government positions.

According to Budapest, this is the kind of autonomy they are talking about – they are not interested in reclaiming territory. The deputy head of the largest Hungarian party in Ukraine, Josef Bortot confirms this. Of the 64 deputies from his party to the regional council, there were 8 ethnic Hungarians. He himself became the first deputy chairman of the Zakarpattia Oblast Council as well as the Deputy Head of the Hungarian party in Ukraine, KMKS. He says that defending interests without politics is impossible and he rejects any manifestations of separatism.

“We want the Hungarians of Zakarpattia region to be able to preserve their identity, so they will have no reason to emigrate and seek a better life abroad,” said Josef Bortot.

Hennadiy Moskal, the head of the Regional State Administration, has established a very good working relationship with the local Hungarian organizations. He ridicules the television stations that raise the nonexistent issues of separatism and talk of widespread lawlessness. He claims it is the Kremlin that is pushing separatism. Hungary has good intentions, he says.

“Hungary’s policy is clear to us, but not that clear to those who never left their village and have never been to Zakarpattia. Emigration of Zakarpattia Hungarians isn’t economically profitable for Hungary. The country merely helps both Ukrainian and Hungarian villages,” says Moskal.

In the interview with TSN, Moskal said that the Kremlin is constantly working to drive a wedge between Budapest and Kyiv, promoting rallies and conferences where separatism is in the spotlight. One such conference was recently disrupted by the Ukrainian security agents. Professor Fedak and Dmytro Tuzhanskyi support Moskal’s statements about Moscow’s intentions to sow discord between Ukrainians and Hungarians. In Hungary recently, Béla Kovács was detained by the Hungarian state prosecutor. A member of Jobbik, Kovács served as a Hungarian deputy of the European Parliament. He had an office in Zakarpattia Oblast. He is being investigated as an agent of the Russian FSB.

“Budapest’s aspirations for the Hungarian community in Ukraine are interpreted in Russian or pro-Russian media in Ukraine as the intention to create an autonomy or to separate,” said Dmytro Tuzhanskyi.

As Hungary is a member of the European Union and NATO, the issue of separatism is not the problem. The problem lies within Ukraine. Ukraine lacks its own policy in how to handle the situation in Transcarpathia.

There is no program in place which would provide the ethnic Hungarians with the opportunity to learn the Ukrainian language. The ethnic Hungarians go to Hungarian schools and Hungarian libraries; they read Hungarian publications. If they want to learn Ukrainian, they have to do that on their own, by hiring a tutor. So it’s not the Hungarians who are the problem, it is the Ukrainians. Ukraine has no federal policy, no national strategy to provide opportunities for those ethnic Hungarians who want to learn the Ukrainian language. Ukraine is not taking advantage of a valuable resource: the Ukrainian-Hungarians. It seems the government of Ukraine is voluntarily creating all the conditions required for Hungarian political autonomy to take root in Transcarpathia.

Ed: The issue of the isolation of the Hungarian community in Ukraine was at the center of Ukraine’s arguments in support of its recently adopted education law, which stipulates that starting from grade 5, Ukrainian will be the language of instruction for ethnic minorities save the Crimean Tatars. The previous situation, when all subjects in schools were studied in the minority languages, led to 60.1% of Hungarian and Romanian school graduates flunking their Ukrainian language exam, barring their road to universities and further career advancement within Ukrainian society, according to Ukraine’s education minister Hrynevych. Ukraine argues that the Hungarians will be better integrated into Ukrainian society when they know Ukrainian better. However, the law has been widely criticized by Hungary, and Orban has gone so far as to suggest using force against Ukraine. More in our article: Experts weigh in on Ukraine’s hotly debated new minority language policy 

Related:

Translated by: Mariia Savrun, Olha Rudakevych
Edited by: Alya Shandra
Source: TSN
Source: Yevropeiska Pravda

Tags: , , ,

  • zorbatheturk

    A far larger chunk of Hungarian territory was given to Romania after WW1. Romania then comprised mostly four different ethnic groups: Romanians, Magyars, Roma, and Saxons. The Saxons had been there for 800 years – most have now left and moved to (what was then) West Germany, where they were given apartments and pensions, and an exit fee was paid by Bonn to Bucharest in hard currency: DM. Nice little earner for Ceausescu, the commie dictator. Some of their empty houses are now inhabited by Roma – gypsies.

    I think the Krumlin is stoking this Hungarian/Ukraine tension.

    • Oknemfrod

      >I would not be at all surprised if it is the Krumlin who is stoking this Hungarian/Ukraine tension. Typical RuSSian playbook.<

      It's exactly what it is. The official Hungary isn't going to make any territorial claims on Ukraine, unless they want to be expelled from the EU and join an alliance with Russia instead – which ain't gonna happen, no matter what faction should come to dominate the Hungarian government; the Hungarians at large remember 1956 all too well.

      A scenario under which Hungary would decide to take over Zakarpattia by force is crazier by an order of magnitude by virtue of its sheer idiocy alone, not to mention that the Hungarian army of less than 50k active personnel in total is no match for the battle-hardened Ukrainian armed forces. In fact, merely writing the preceding sentence makes me cringe for nothing else but just imagining the possibility of such a disaster as this kind of encounter. The Krumblin may have it in its wet dreams, but it ain't not gonna happen.

      • Микола Данчук

        Lets skip the macho approach, conflict serves no rational purpose.
        The world today should not reflect whose bones are buried deepest but on how we as a people can insure that all our children and all their children can make this world a better place for all mankind.

        • Oknemfrod

          Precisely what I had in mind. Perhaps should’ve phrased it more clearly but no machismo was intended: by the “disaster” I meant, not someone’s defeat, but the mere thought of a U-H territorial conflict.

          • Микола Данчук

            Ukraine needs a strong defensive force true but it also needs an intellectual approach when dealing with irrational arguments which attack it in concept. The history is long even when muddled by others who may resent who we are because they may lack an identity as complex as ours.
            Don’t start a fight but make sure you can finish one, mentally and physically.

          • Oknemfrod

            Agreed.

        • slavko

          This is a top comment you made Микола!!

          • Микола Данчук

            Щиро дякую.

          • slavko

            Прошу будь ласка.

    • Screwdriver
      • zorbatheturk

        Young Putin putting it in.

  • Tony

    Do like Slovakia and financially punish such attempts on your territory while funding Ukrainian education an local pro Ukraine cultural development.

    Also, go right ahead and do the same to russia. Promote Ukrainianization in neighboring russian areas and promote discord there.

  • Ihor Dawydiak

    When was this article written?? It stated that Ukraine had no federal policy to provide ethnic Hungarian citizens of Ukraine with a reasonable fiscal opportunity to become fluent in the Ukrainian language. Now this may have some relevance with some or even many adult ethnic Hungarians but it should no longer pertain to students who are still in school. Why? The new Ukrainian language law that was recently passed by the Verkhovna Rada, promulgated into force by President Poroshenko’s signature and then formally announced by the Government sanctioned newspaper, Holos Ukrayiny, has made the study of the Ukrainian language obligatory in every public school in Ukraine. As for any notion by Hungarian crackpots calling for the annexation of Transcarpathia to Hungary, this entire idea was stillborn from the time of its conception and in all probability it was hatched at least in part by Kremlin provocateurs. In short, Hungary (even if they wanted to) does not have the ability to seize this region nor will they ever have that ability. As such, this entire matter should be considered as nothing more than “a tempest in a teapot”.

  • Микола Данчук

    Curious,
    What would Hungary do if other ethnic groups (in Hungary) demanded specific rights and privileges on the Governments dime?
    Or as historic precedence?
    How far back can this go to be relevant?

  • Csíkos Kocka

    show a 1920 Ukrainian map

  • Screwdriver

    Stupid Kiev Nazi regime did not have enough problems, so decided to create some more, with suppose to be European friends.
    As a result regime is about to get kicked out from EU association.