FSB may be well pleased with Zapad-2017 outcome, Belarusian analysts say

Russian self-propelled guns in Vereitsy, Belarus during Zapad-2017 (Image: belsat.eu)

Russian self-propelled guns in Vereitsy, Belarus during Zapad-2017 (Image: belsat.eu) 

International, More

The Zapad-2017 military exercise has ended “without the annexation of Belarus, a new round of aggression against Ukraine, or the triggering of World War III” that many had predicted or feared, Igor Ilyash point out in a new commentary. And those are all good things.

But the Belarusian analyst argues that those pleased that these things did not happen should nonetheless not look away from what happened and instead consider how the FSB or the GRU in Moscow may be evaluating this enormous military exercise because it will be their judgments about that which will shape the future.

And in a new Belsat commentary, Ilyash offers five conclusions that he believes the Russian authorities are most likely to have drawn about “the Belarusian aspect of the Zapad-2017 exercise.”

First of all, he says, the Russian security services are completely correct to assume that “the attitude toward the Russian military among the main part of the population of Belarus is either quite loyal or absolutely indifferent.” Few Belarusians criticized the Russian forces and most accepted their appearance as something quite normal.

Second, Ilyash continues, Moscow is likely to conclude that “civil society is very weak [in Belarus] and is not capable of mobilizing anti-Russian protests even in those cases when pressure isn’t being applied to it.” Minsk showed that by allowing the opposition to organize a tiny demonstration against the Russian forces.

But all that did, the Belsat journalist says, was to underscore to Moscow that “any accusations of Russophobia in Belarus are baseless” and that “only ‘a handful of marginals’ are prepared to speak out against the Kremlin.”

Tanks of the Russian 4th Guards Kantemirovskaya Tank Division in Vereitsy, Belarus (Image: belsat.eu)

Tanks of the Russian 4th Guards Kantemirovskaya Tank Division in Vereitsy, Belarus (Image: belsat.eu)

Third, Moscow is certain to conclude that “public control was lacking and that no monitoring of Russian forces on the territory of Belarus was carried out.” In many cases, that would have been quite easy to do and it would have allowed for precise measurements of the size and movements of troops. But it wasn’t done.

Instead, Belarusians and Belarusian officials continued to act as if nothing was happening, and that in turn lends credence to the Kantemirovskaya Tank Division soldier who said “if we wanted to occupy you, we would have, and you wouldn’t have understood anything. We would simply have come in and your officers would have become [non-ethnic] Russians.”

Fourth, Ilyash suggests, the FSB and the GRU are almost certain to have concluded that “the Belarusian authorities do not have even elementary ideas about the principles of conducting information war. The state media and press services are not capable of reacting in a timely fashion to releases [from the other side] and in general don’t consider that necessary.”

And fifth, and perhaps most important, the Russians will have concluded that “even the politically active part of society does not believe in the Russian threat, does not take it seriously and therefore no one should count on a rapid reaction in the case of a deterioration of the situation.”


Yes, some Belarusians talked about Veyshnoria, the imaginary enemy country, Ilyash says; but far more paid attention on Facebook to Mikhail Saakashvili’s return to Ukraine than to the actions of Russian tanks on their own national territory.

If these are in fact the conclusions that Moscow has reached, then Zapad-2017 is not so much about something that didn’t happen but rather a test for something that may yet happen in the future – especially because so many in the West are celebrating what didn’t happen and concluding that since it didn’t, it won’t.


Edited by: A. N.

Dear readers! Since you’ ve made it to this point, we have a favor to ask. Russia’s hybrid war against Ukraine is ongoing, but major news agencies have gone away, which is why it's extra important to provide news about Ukraine in English. We are a small independent journalist team on a shoestring budget, have no political or state affiliation, and depend on our readers to keep going (using the chanсe - a big thank you to our generous supporters, we couldn't make it without you.)  If you like what you see, please help keep us online with a donation

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,


    1. Avatar Rafael Hernandez says:

      I don’t really understand what you mean. In Russa you can speak about what you want, as your link proved. Russia is truly a democratic country, that explains why so many Ukrainians are going there

      1. Avatar Brent says:

        “Ralphie”, you’re as clueless as ever!!! Let me guess….you’ll next claim Russia is the “cleanest” when it comes to anti-doping policies for its athletes?

        If Russia is so great, why don’t you even claim to live there? You claim to live in Oslo instead…. https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/32eabe5b3c1625d760b15c32d0f291bf9c24e7e18465f6c2186c626d9afc4e11.jpg

        1. Avatar Rafael Hernandez says:

          Actually Russia is now by far the country in the world with the toughest anti-doping rules. Every single Russian were clean in Rio and London, as opposed to Ukrsine who had 8 ex-dopers in Rio. Just because I live in Norway does not mean I can voice my opinion. I will never forget what Russia did for my country in ww2. I also commend Russia for standing up to Nato, and not allow it to do a Libya or Serbia on Belarus or Russia. Obviously you are too Russophobic to understand this

          1. Avatar zorbatheturk says:

            All RuSSians are dopers.

          2. Avatar Brent says:

            If Russia was so “anti-doping”, why are there so many of you dopey trolls?

            What exactly did Russia do for Norway in WWII? Align with Nazzi Germany who invaded Norway???

            Was your grandpappy Vidkun Quisling? That would explain a lot…your love of Nazzi’s and admiration of invading forces….

  1. Avatar veth says:

    Prosecutors seize Azarov’s son assets in Ukraine, Italy and Switzerland
    “The arrest came as part of the criminal investigation against Azarov’s son for illegal enrichment.

    Arrested were land sites in Ukraine and Italy, cars, bank deposits in Switzerland,” Prosecutor General’s Office said, answering an inquiry by UNN Sept. 23.

    Earlier, the Pechersk court in Kyiv allowed prosecutors to arrest 10 bank accounts of Azarov’s son. Читайте більше тут: http://zik.ua/en/news/2017/09/24/prosecutors_seize_azarovs_son_assets_in_ukraine_italy_and_switzerland_1173333

    1. Avatar Алексей Синяев says:

      It’s all. …?

      1. Avatar veth says:

        9000 troops still in Donbass

  2. Avatar Screwdriver says:

    “civil society is very weak [in Belarus] and is not capable of mobilizing anti-Russian protests”
    Why would Belarussians do something stupid ? They know about Ukraine experience with Maidans, who needs that mess and turmoil ?
    Good for them, smart people.

    1. Avatar Brent says:

      Claims the Russo Nazzi who fled to South Philly to clean toilets instead of being a man and standing up and fighting for the Russian terrorists he supports….

  3. Avatar zorbatheturk says:

    RuSzsian FSB are a bunch of c#ck biting f#cktards.