Russia preparing for war in the media but not in the budget, Moscow commentators say

Mi-8 combat helicopters participating in the Russian military exercises "Caucasus-2016" in Russia's Southern Military District near Ukraine (Image: TASS)

Mi-8 combat helicopters participating in the Russian military exercises "Caucasus-2016" in Russia's Southern Military District near Ukraine (Image: TASS) 

Analysis & Opinion, Military analysis, Russia

The Moscow media are filled with stories suggesting that Russia is preparing for war, but a close examination of the Russian government budget calls that conclusion into question, leaving open an even larger one: will this media firestorm lead to a real one or will it burn out of its own accord?

Anyone who has followed the news from Moscow over the last several weeks, the Meduza portal notes, has to conclude that “Russia is preparing for war. The newspapers and television channels are talking about sudden checks of the military and military exercises … the construction and location of bomb shelters … and rations … in the event of military action.”

Ekaterina Schulmann

Ekaterina Schulmann

But a close examination of the Russian state budget, Ekaterina Schulmann of the Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration says, shows that

“Spending on defense is not growing but declining.” What is growing is spending for agencies that can suppress “domestic disorders.”

“If someone thinks that we are preparing for a world war,” Schulmann says, “this isn’t visible” from the budget. “If we are preparing for something, then it is for some kind of internal disorders. We intend to feed our defense ministry a little less and to feed out special services and interior force structures more,” at least judging from the budget.

Oleg Kashin

Oleg Kashin

But can what is going on in the media lead to something real, can the war on television become a war in reality? That is a question Moscow commentator Oleg Kashin addresses because he says if the current situation were a movie, the news would be a leading indicator.

That may not be the case now, he suggests, because

for the current Russian elite, “foreign policy always was only a continuation of domestic policy.” All of Putin’s words and actions are addressed in the first instance to the people of the Russian Federation and are intended to ensure that he and his entourage will remain in power.

Talking about war is one thing – it may be very good politics – but going to war is something else because it would destroy almost everything that Putin has achieved up to this point and cast doubt on his ability to remain in power in any meaningful war, the commentator continues.

To be sure, Kashin says, “we really can’t imagine what is in the heads” of the people in the Kremlin, the former KGB officers. “The little pictures which they draw for internal use have begun suddenly to come alive,” and thinking about what that could mean has got to be horrible for them, as does backing down, given the domestic consequences of doing so.

“What is to be done? They do not know.” They know how to ramp up anger but they aren’t prepared to live with taking the obvious next step.

Sergey Shoygu likes playing military commander but only as long as it is play and not the real thing, Kashin argues, given what he has to know a real war would amount to.

Everything Putin has done, the Moscow commentator says, has been “subordinate to a single goal, that his power will be beyond dispute and that no one else will have the opportunity to make politician decisions … Long ago [he and his entourage] achieved this, and now, they don’t have anyone to divide responsibility for what they have brought about.”


Edited by: A. N.

Since you’re here – we have a favor to ask. Russia’s hybrid war against Ukraine is ongoing, but major news agencies have gone away. But we’re here to stay, and will keep on providing quality, independent, open-access information on Ukrainian reforms, Russia’s hybrid war, human rights violations, political prisoners, Ukrainian history, and more. We are a non-profit, don’t have any political sponsors, and never will. If you like what you see, please help keep us online with a donation!

Tags: , , , , ,

  • ZarkoI

    What kind of garbage is this? You should pay attention to your declining or non-existent living standards in Ukraine. Your Nazi’s want the EU, well here you go, have fun. Your government is so sick and corrupted you will not join the EU or have a visa free status for 20 years. Your government is run by foreigners who are destroying any future Ukraine might have had, obviously not thinking about your children, or future generations. Shame on you all.

    • zorbatheturk

      Wrong, Igor. It is RuSSiya that has no future.

      • Quartermaster


    • Turtler

      You want to talk about garbage?

      You accuse them of being “Nazis.” But Nazis means National Socialist GERMAN Workers’ Party.

      How many Ukrainians fit in with that? Or even German?

  • zorbatheturk

    You want a war you goddam stinking Russki scumbuckets YOU BETTER BE PREPARED TO LOSE! The West has had enough of your Soviet nonsense.

  • Quartermaster

    Russia can not afford a war. She doesn’t have the money for it, nor the Army.

  • shucky

    The Democrats are tempting fate by rattling the saber and scoffing at Russian resolve. Don’t be surprised if China, North Korea, Iran, Venezuela and Cuba tag along.

    Trump offers cooperation and Putin returns his sentiments. I vote for peace and strength, not leftist emasculation of the military, idle accusations and belligerence.

    • Turtler

      The problem is that Putin is diametrically opposed to Western Strength, much less cooperation or peace. So even as a Trump supporter I have few illusions. He will remain a threat and he will remain at primary fault for what he does.

  • Dagwood Bumstead

    The article pretty much ignores that Dwarfstan already IS at war. It is fighting two wars, in the Donbas and in Syria- even though the dwarf denies involvement in the Donbas. Nobody with a brain is fooled by the dwarf’s denials, however.