Putin and Gerasimov inflate battlefield wins, but ISW data exposes the gap

ISW says Gerasimov claimed 50% of Kostiantynivka; verified data shows 1.6%.
Russian President Vladimir Putin pins a medal on a servicemember during an awards ceremony on 17 December 2025, surrounded by military officers in dress uniforms
Putin awards medals to Russian servicemembers on 17 December 2025, where he claimed Russia had seized “strategically important settlements” and vowed to achieve all war goals. Photo: kremlin.ru
Putin and Gerasimov inflate battlefield wins, but ISW data exposes the gap

Russian President Putin and Chief of the General Staff Valery Gerasimov continue to publicly exaggerate battlefield gains while reaffirming Moscow's commitment to its original maximalist war aims.

The inflated claims appear designed to convince the West that Ukrainian defenses are collapsing — a narrative ISW says the Kremlin is pushing to pressure Kyiv and its partners into accepting Russian demands ahead of potential peace talks.

Putin claimed on 17 December that Russian forces had seized Siversk and other "strategically important settlements." ISW assessed that Russian forces have seized only about 77 percent of Siversk.

Gerasimov went further, telling foreign military attachés on 18 December that Russia controls Kupiansk — despite mounting evidence that Ukrainian forces are liberating significant portions of the town — and that Russian troops hold 50 percent of Kostiantynivka.

Russian leaders claim three times more than actual control

ISW found no evidence supporting Gerasimov's Kostiantynivka claim. The think tank assessed that Russian forces have seized just 1.6 percent of the town while maintaining a presence within only five percent through infiltration missions or assaults.

Even pro-war Russian milbloggers — typically inclined to amplify Moscow's narrative — claim only 11 percent control, far below Gerasimov's figure.

During a 17 December ceremony awarding medals to Russian servicemembers, Putin declared that Russia will achieve all of its goals. A recipient of the Hero of Russia medal stated that Russian forces are fulfilling Putin's mandate to seize Russia's "ancestral lands."

Putin's statements align with his recent public rhetoric indicating his commitment to the 2022 maximalist war aims, which ISW assesses means he will not accept a peace agreement based on the US-proposed 28-point plan.

2025 territorial gains: smaller than Delaware

Gerasimov claimed Russian forces have seized over 6,300 square kilometers in 2025 — slightly more than Defense Minister Andrei Belousov's 17 December claim of 6,000 square kilometers. ISW assessed Russia has actually seized approximately 4,700 square kilometers this year.

Even accepting Gerasimov's inflated figure, it amounts to just 1.04 percent of Ukraine's total territory — an area only slightly larger than the US state of Delaware.

ISW noted that these exaggerated claims actually undermine the Kremlin's own cognitive warfare effort to portray a Russian battlefield victory and Ukrainian defensive collapse as inevitable. Gerasimov appears to have used his briefing to foreign military officials to amplify claims from Putin's and Belousov's addresses at the 17 December Russian Defense Ministry board meeting.

Same script, different briefing

This pattern of exaggeration is not new. In October, ISW reported that even Russian milbloggers were publicly dismissing Gerasimov's claims of encircling Ukrainian troops near Pokrovsk and Kupiansk as fiction, with one describing the battlefield situation as "100% chaos."

ISW also assessed on 18 December that Defense Minister Belousov's claims about quickly seizing Ukraine's "Fortress Belt" were undermined by his own timeline — Russian troops have been trying to seize Pokrovsk alone for nearly 140 days.

To suggest a correction or clarification, write to us here

You can also highlight the text and press Ctrl + Enter

Please leave your suggestions or corrections here



    Euromaidan Press

    We are an independent media outlet that relies solely on advertising revenue to sustain itself. We do not endorse or promote any products or services for financial gain. Therefore, we kindly ask for your support by disabling your ad blocker. Your assistance helps us continue providing quality content. Thank you!

    Related Posts

    Ads are disabled for Euromaidan patrons.

    Support us on Patreon for an ad-free experience.

    Already with us on Patreon?

    Enter the code you received on Patreon or by email to disable ads for 6 months

    Invalid code. Please try again

    Code successfully activated

    Ads will be hidden for 6 months.