APR04 Bucha Kyiv region territory of the children_s camp. Basement. All died with their hands tied. Everyone was tortured, some had their legs shot, some had 5 bullets in their hearts 4 genocide

Bucha, Kyiv Oblast, 4 April. On the territory of the children's camp civilians were found in the basement. All died with their hands tied. Everyone was tortured, some had their legs shot, some had 5 bullets in their hearts. Source: Dattalion 

Hybrid War

Article by: Orysia Hrudka
Edited by: Michael Garrood

Editor’s Note

Ukrainian MP Iryna Gerashchenko told Euromaidan Press about the so-called press tour to Mariupol for international journalists Russia was planning to organize, the necessary sanctions to eliminate Russian propaganda for the war, the need to prosecute not only major Russian propagandists but all involved in the war crimes against Ukraine, the case of Marina Ovsyannikova and the danger of glorifying ex-propagandists instead of amplifying voices of journalists covering the war in Ukraine.

In May 2022, three committees of the Ukrainian Verkhovna Rada appealed to national parliaments in EU and NATO member states as well as major international institutions to sanction Russian propaganda as part of the Russian military machine. This would include media organs and persons involved in disseminating propaganda along with their families.Euromaidan Press spoke to two Ukrainian MPs who worked on this appeal – Iryna Herashchenko from the European Solidarity Party and Oleksandr Merezhko from the Servant of the People Party.

Ukrainian journalists Russian propaganda interview

Iryna Herashchenko. Photo by Viktor Kovalchuk

Ukrainian intelligence said Russia may be planning to organize a staged “press tour” to Mariupol for international journalists.

This is not the first time that the Russian occupational authorities have used their dirty methods to organize such press tours and transport not only their propaganda media but also respectable Western media to the occupied territories.

It is obvious that Western agencies and TV channels will agree to these conditions because this is the only chance to see with their own eyes what now goes on in Mariupol.

In my opinion, there is a very fine line between a journalist’s duty to inform and the propaganda in which Russian propagandists are now trying to involve the whole world in order to relaunch the lies that Ukraine is at war with Ukraine [the Russian propagandists spread messages about a “civil war” in Ukraine in and after 2014] and about nationalists from whom Russians allegedly defend Mariupol. Therefore, it seems to me that Ukraine needs to remember that this is a hybrid war, where the information component is as important as the full-scale aggression itself.

https://twitter.com/EuromaidanPress/status/1519464913210462210

How can this information propaganda component Russia’s war aggression be fought?

We, the European Solidarity Party, believe that a Bucha List should be created. The name of the list is comes from the Kyiv suburb of Bucha, through which the entire civilized world received its first from Russian atrocities that carried elements of genocide.

The perpetrators of this genocide are certainly the Russian propagandists who for years have been brainwashing the Russian society that there is Nazism in Ukraine, that Ukraine needs to be liberated from someone, that Russian-speaking people are oppressed, that some “Banderas” need to be destroyed so on. Russian propagandists became the instigators of Russian crimes in Ukraine.

Russian propagandists must be tried for inciting genocide and war – international lawyer

It is very wrong when only Margarita Simonyan, Vladimir Solovyov, Yevgeny Kiselyov, and Olga Skabeyeva are included on this list. Because they are, so to speak, colonels of the information front; but soldiers, majors, sergeants, al those who offered ammunition to this information front have the same responsibility for brainwashing first their compatriots, and then a part of Ukrainians.

Therefore, the entire editorial board of Russia Today, Russia 24, RIA Novosti, TASS, and other Russian news agencies and TV channels should be included in the Bucha List.

Russian propagandists

Vladimir Putin during a visit to the new RT broadcasting center. Source: Wikimedia Commons

In addition, the Bucha List should include all those guests of the Russian talk shows who, foaming at the mouth, talked about the need to turn Ukraine into nuclear dust and who do brainwashed the Russians that they do not believe that Russia is killing Ukrainians here, even when their Ukrainian relatives say so. Instead, Russians respond that “you are all to blame for everything and Putin has tolerated you for so long.” Who should be responsible for the fact that they say so?

Putin triples spending on state media to promote his war in Ukraine

What can the EU do to combat Russian propaganda?

Since 2014 our party has been fighting very hard to shut down all Russian propaganda sites and media in all European countries so that this, so to speak, poison does not reach Berlin, Paris, and other European cities where it works as well.

Another thing I personally worked on for a long time was the appropriate vocabulary. The French media wrote for a long time that the Russian-controlled troops in Donbas are “rebels,” or “separatists.” These are not separatists, there have always been regular units of the Russian army and the FSB. Therefore, it is very important to continue to insist on the correct vocabulary and react harshly.

Not only about the vocabulary about Russia, but also about Ukraine, so that there would not be all these imaginary Nazi battalions, as the Azov Regiment which has defended Mariupol is often called.

Hunting fascism in Ukraine, you overlooked fascism in Russia

And finally: I have already addressed a similar initiative to the Ukrainian authorities and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. There must be a very strict vetting of foreign journalists working in Ukraine. All those who worked at least one day in Russian propaganda media, for example for Russia Today, should not receive accreditation in Ukraine. That’s fair.

In the West, there is still a lack of understanding of Russia’s hybrid methods of warfare. Marina Ovsyannikova is already recognized as a hero, mentioned in speeches of world leaders, and was hired at Die Welt, despite the fact that coming out with an anti-war poster on air of Russian propaganda TV could well be a special operation.

Sorry, but the real heroes are Ukrainian journalists. Max Levin is a hero, not those who lied for so many years, fooled their society, completely sharing Putin’s hateful ideology, and now they are elements of promoting the thesis of “good Russians” who are not to blame for the war in Ukraine. I see a very big threat in this thesis. Or, at best, some Russian journalists are just very cunning and now want to whitewash their reputation and continue to work in the profession, but now abroad.

Maks Levin, photographer of Russian war against Ukraine since 2014, killed by Russian troops near Kyiv

In my view, if a person repents for her actions, let her now atone with actions. Instead, Marina Ovsyannikova is proposed to be nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize. This is nonsense which discredits these awards. Moreover, it offends Ukrainian journalists and journalists from other countries who have really risked their lives in Ukraine. There are already two dozen murdered media representatives. There are also those who have been taken captive. And against their background, many say that a very brave girl held a placard for a minute.

A group of Ukrainian journalists and cultural figures signed an open letter to Die Welt about the risks of truthful coverage of events in Ukraine by Marina Ovsyannikova, calling on Die Welt to reconsider its decision on what issues and countries Maryna Ovsyannikova will cover:

“The decision of Die Welt to appoint a former editor of a Russian propaganda TV channel to speak about Ukraine, when Ukraine is fighting for the right to finally speak for itself and when it is absolutely necessary to increase journalistic voices from Ukraine and not from Russia, is outrageous. We think that with this decision Die Welt contributes more to the imperialist division of the world than to building a democracy in which each state has the right to its own voice.”

Russian ex propagandist

Marina Ovsyannikova wearing a necklace with the colors of Ukrainian and Russian flags. Source: Ovsyannikova’s video address

The signatories of the letter stressed that despite Marina Ovsyannikova emphasizing her Ukrainian roots and solidarity with Ukraine, she could not even pronounce the words “Ukraine” and “Ukrainian” correctly (she was making the wrong emphasis) and could not take responsibility for the war by her home country. They stressed that Ovsyannikova also speaks of the war as a “fratricidal” war between two “fraternal peoples” and thus spreads the Russian propaganda myth of the fraternal peoples of Ukraine and Russia.

The authors of the letter also pointed out that the fine she was given by Russian authorities (about EUR 250) was surprisingly small given the new Russian law on fakes, which has already entered into force in the Russian Federation as of March 14.

“In her text, ‘Russians are afraid’ Marina Ovsyannikova tells how humanitarian aid was organized for Ukrainian refugees in Russia’s Kaluga Oblast but does not express any doubts about whether the Ukrainian women and men wete ‘evacuated’ to Russia of their own goodwill, does not say a single word about abductions and deportations Russia conducts in occupied territories of Ukraine. These and other gaps in Ukraine’s knowledge and understanding, as well as active participation in anti-Ukrainian propaganda in the past, have disqualified her as an expert on Ukraine.”

The letter is available in German and Ukrainian

It seems to me that, globally, the world has not yet found an answer as to what to do with Russia. Finally, the world is helping Ukraine with weapons and imposing sanctions on Russia.

Yet the idea that there is another good Russia still exists. But there is no good Russia if 80% of Russians support Putin and this “special operation.” Others are still silent. They allowed this story to take place. That is why Russia must be held accountable. It is very ridiculous now to say that someone is good because someone suddenly came to their senses.

At our level, as politicians, as statesmen, we convey to the partners our position about the inadmissibility, in fact, about the insult to Ukrainian society to hire all these Ovsyannikovs and even mention them as examples of “enlightened mind.” But it must be a systematic state work.

Russian propagandists war against Ukraine

Inside RIA Novosti news agency. Photograph: Maiak.info, CC licence

Do you think that Russian propaganda has changed somehow after 24 February 2022?

It has not changed and is working at full capacity. First, Russian propagandists continue to brainwash their society. The key task of Russian propagandists is to ensure support of Russians for the war. They need Putin to continue to have 80% legitimacy. They continue to send these aggressive, absolutely fascist messages. They say that Ukraine must be destroyed. Then they threaten the whole world with nuclear weapons. They threaten Great Britain and the United States. It is a language of hatred and a search for reasons why Ukraine should be attacked.

How Russia’s worst propaganda myths about Ukraine seep into media language

How can Russian propagandists be brought to responsibility for inciting war against Ukraine?

First, Russian propagandists should be on the sanctions list, to have their accounts and property arrested. Because not only Vladimir Solovyov has a house on Lake Como. They all made a living from propaganda.

Second, propaganda TV channels must be switched off.

And third, if we talk about the criminal liability of Russian propagandists, this mechanism is a bit more complicated. Here it is necessary to record Russian propagandists’ crimes, all these calls for bombing on Ukraine, and so on, so that they are held accountable.

It seems to me that the Ukrainian state has not worked hard to gather evidence of Russian crimes since 2014, so today the priority is to clearly record all crimes of propaganda, of violence, and murder. In addition to the information about the orders, the captured Russian soldiers should also be asked who motivated them to commit crimes and to attack Ukraine in general. I think they will lead us to these propagandists.

screenshot from Rossiya 1 video

Screenshot from Russia-controlled Rossiya 1 channel video where Dmitry Kiselyov talks about Russia’s readiness to turn its enemies into “radioactive dust.”

We are currently improving Ukrainian legislation, introducing clear rules on what war crimes are. Among others, we must very clearly single out propaganda campaigns, which are in fact an incitement to war crimes. Also, at the level of political dialogue with the world, once the propagandists are on the sanctions list, it will be much easier to promote not only sanctions but also criminal liability.

I personally never give interviews to any Russian media because there are no good Russians. This is obvious. They are all responsible for building not just a dictatorship but fascism in their country. And that this country attacked Ukraine. It is hard to imagine anyone giving an interview to German Nazi propaganda media during World War II.

Russian propaganda is a war tool and must be ostracized – military expert

But Ukrainian TV continues to include “good Russians” in their programs, promoting this very topic that it’s not that straightforward, that the truth is somewhere in the middle. At the same time, they ignore the fact that Russian opposition leaders themselves promoted the ideas of “Slavism” instead of protesting in Russia. I think they allowed this monster to be born.

Unfortunately, the Ukrainian Ministry of Culture and Information is currently engaged in political censorship, when it shuts down three undesirable channels and creates lists of undesirable politicians for the state telethon. Martial law, of course, warrants certain restrictions and responsibilities for state political forces and politicians, but this is no reason to impose political censorship.

On 3 May 2022, three committees of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine adopted a decision to counter Russian propaganda and appealed to the national parliaments of the EU and NATO member states, the European Parliament, the Parliamentary Assemblies of the Council of Europe, NATO, the OSCE and the Inter-Parliamentary Union with the following requests:

“We call for tougher sanctions on Russian institutions involved in disinformation, propaganda, and media manipulation, and for sanctions to be imposed on those involved in its development and dissemination, as well as on members of their families.

We urge the world media not to cooperate with former employees of Russian propaganda outlets and not to expose their audiences to the danger of falling victim to Russian psychological operations.

We call for an end to the broadcasting of Russian media via satellite systems, as such resources are used by Russia exclusively to pursue aggressive political, economic, and military goals of the Russian Federation, completely ignoring the need to adhere to standards of journalistic ethics. Instead, we urge satellite providers to involve Ukrainian broadcasters in their broadcasts.

We call on all media to refrain from spreading Russian propaganda narratives and not to provide a platform for Russian propagandists to spread lies and misinformation. We call on the administrators of social networks, video hosting services, and other media platforms to stop the spread of Russian disinformation and propaganda, to make additional efforts to verify information published on such resources for Russian lies and manipulations, and not to promote Russian propaganda and incitements for violence”

On 2 March 2022 the Council of the European Union announced that the EU will suspend the broadcasting activities of Sputnik and RT/Russia Today (RT English, RT UK, RT Germany, RT France, and RT Spanish) in the EU, or directed at the EU, “until the aggression to Ukraine is put to an end, and until the Russian Federation and its associated outlets cease to conduct disinformation and information manipulation actions against the EU and its member states.”

Related:

Edited by: Michael Garrood

Ukraine needs independent journalism. And we need you. Join our community on Patreon and help us better connect Ukraine to the world. We’ll use your contribution to attract new authors, upgrade our website, and optimize its SEO. For as little as the cost of one cup of coffee a month, you can help build bridges between Ukraine and the rest of the world, plus become a co-creator and vote for topics we should cover next. Become a patron or see other ways to support. Become a Patron!

Tags: , , , , ,