After Minsk, another Munich has now taken place in Moscow, Illarionov says

John Kerry and Putin, December 15, 2015 in Moscow

 

2015/12/17 • Analysis & Opinion, Politics

Russian commentators across the political spectrum, from the most liberal to the most nationalistic, agree that Vladimir Putin achieved a significant victory for his policies in Syria and Ukraine in the course and as a result of US Secretary of State John Kerry’s visit to Moscow.

Andrey Illarionov (Image: kasparov.ru)

Andrey Illarionov (Image: kasparov.ru)

One Moscow analyst who regretfully accepts that conclusion but is thoroughly appalled by it is Andrey Illarionov who describes what took place as part and parcel of “the Munich-Minsk-Moscow process,” in which the United States in order to get an agreement has made ever more concessions to Putin.

Illarionov makes that point by listing “the brief results of the visits of J. Kerry to Moscow in December:”

First, he writes, this marked “the end of the so-called ‘Putin isolation.’” After three meetings of Putin and Barack Obama “over the last two and a half months, after Hollande’s visit to the Kremlin and Putin’s trip to Paris, after two visits by Kerry to Russia in this year, it isn’t appropriate to speak about any international isolation of the current Russian regime.”

Indeed, Kerry himself declared that isolating Putin was not American policy. In response to a Russia Today journalist who pointed out that Obama had said about a year ago that “it is America that currently stands strong and united with the allies, but Russia is the one that’s isolated,” the US secretary of state declared that isn’t American policy.

“Now, we don’t seek to isolate Russia as a matter of policy, no. At that particular moment of time, there was an effort to try to make a statement about what had happened… Today, we met here as a matter of good diplomacy to try to solve problems, and I believe we will continue that effort in New York on Friday.”

“There is no policy of the United States per se to isolate Russia,” Kerry concluded.

Second, Illarionov continues, the US has now accepted Putin’s call for “a joint coalition of Russia and the US for ‘the resolution of common problems.” Kerry declared in Moscow that “we have consistently said that the world is better off when Russia and the United States find common ground and an ability to be able to work together.”

The top US diplomat added that “It’s a sign of the maturity of both leaders and their understanding of the importance of the role they play… There is a policy of the United States… to try to work with Russia to join together in as constructive a way as possible to, as I said a moment ago, find the common ground.”

Third, the Moscow analyst says, despite the failure of Russia’s military operation in Syria and “the impossibility of saving the Assad regime with force alone… Putin without difficulty convinced the Nobel aspirant to shift to ‘a political process,’ to diplomatic negotiations about the preservation of Assad as head of Syria.”

Despite the fact that the US had declared many times that no solution in Syria would be possible as long as Assad remained in power, Kerry said in Moscow: “As I emphasized today, the United States and our partners are not seeking so-called ‘regime change,’ as it is known in Syria.”

Consequently, the future of Syria will now be decided not by negotiations of the Syrian opposition groups without Assad and not by negotiations in which both the opposition groups and Assad are participants but rather, Illarionov points out, by talks between Assad and “a delegation of the unified opposition,” thus tilting the outcome in his favor.

Fourth, Kerry disowned, as Moscow had already, the decision by “Muslim counties, tired of the exceptionally flexible position of the current American administration” to form “an Islamic military coalition of 34 countries” to oppose ISIS and Assad. And immediately after Kerry did so, Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov “immediately agreed” with the US secretary of state.

Fifth, Kerry again discussed Ukraine once again with the leaders of the country that are the aggressors in Ukraine “but without the participation of Ukraine, the victim of this aggressor,” Illarionov notes.

Specifically, the US secretary of state said “I also underscored today the need to take steps with respect to the implementation of the Minsk agreements and our efforts mutually to try to bring an end to the conflict in Ukraine. We had a good discussion about Ukraine and we agreed on the spot that we will continue to grow out the bilateral process that the presidents agreed on and established recently – some months ago, as a matter of fact.”

Moreover, Kerry made it clear that from Washington’s perspective the situation in Ukraine is one in which both Russia and Ukraine are in violation of the Minsk Accords, noting that “President Putin has agreed on steps that need to be taken. The government in Kyiv also has steps that we agree need to be taken, and we intend to work hard in order to see that both sides’ obligations under this agreement are met.”

Finally, signaling just how pleased he was with his visit to Moscow, Kerry did not conceal from the public his complete satisfaction with what he had been able to achieve jointly with dear ‘Sergey’ (he used that expression five times) and with ‘President Putin’ (whom he thanked three times).” Summing up, Kerry said “so this was a productive day.”

What happened in Moscow, of course, was a classic example of what occurs when one side has a consistent policy and is prepared to wait for others to move and when the other side doesn’t and with time makes more and more concessions to the first in order to get some kind of agreement, even if it is one that violates the latter’s principles and earlier declarations.

  • Putin's military aggression in Donbas devastated Ukrainian territories under the Russian occupation (Image: Novosti Segodnia)
    Putin's military aggression in Donbas devastated Ukrainian territories under the Russian occupation (Image: Novosti Segodnia)
  • Devastation in the Donbas - the product of Putin's military aggression into peaceful Ukraine. (Image: Slavyansk Delovoy)
    Devastation in the Donbas - the product of Putin's military aggression into peaceful Ukraine. (Image: Slavyansk Delovoy)
  • A funeral for unidentified soldiers killed in action liberating the Donbas region of Ukraine from the hybrid army of the Russian Federation. The funeral was held in the town of Kushugum, Zaphorizhze oblast, on October 1, 2014.
    A funeral for unidentified soldiers killed in action liberating the Donbas region of Ukraine from the hybrid army of the Russian Federation. The funeral was held in the town of Kushugum, Zaphorizhze oblast, on October 1, 2014.
  • Russian mercenaries in Donbas
    Russian mercenaries in Donbas
  • The photo of a little girl receiving the metal of her father, Andriy Matviyenko, killed in the Donbas, that was massively blocked by Facebook "for nakedness."
    The photo of a little girl receiving the metal of her father, Andriy Matviyenko, killed in the Donbas, that was massively blocked by Facebook "for nakedness."
  • Russian Federation servicemen from Chechnia arriving in Donbas in 2014 (Image: AFP)
    Russian Federation servicemen from Chechnia arriving in Donbas in 2014 (Image: AFP)
  • Devastation caused by Russian aggression in Donbas, Ukraine (village of Peski) (Image: http://maxrokotansky.livejournal.com)
    Devastation caused by Russian aggression in Donbas, Ukraine (village of Peski) (Image: http://maxrokotansky.livejournal.com)
  • Russian neo-Nazi mercenary Alexey Milchakov photographed next to the corpse of a tortured Ukrainian soldier after an ambush on his vehicle. Donbas, Ukraine (Image: Milchakov's social network page)
    Russian neo-Nazi mercenary Alexey Milchakov photographed next to the corpse of a tortured Ukrainian soldier after an ambush on his vehicle. Donbas, Ukraine (Image: Milchakov's social network page)
  • Devastation caused by Russian aggression in Donbas, Ukraine (village of Peski) (Image: http://maxrokotansky.livejournal.com)
    Devastation caused by Russian aggression in Donbas, Ukraine (village of Peski) (Image: http://maxrokotansky.livejournal.com)
  • Russian mercenary at the devasted Donetsk airport in Donbas, Ukraine (Image: LB.ua)
    Russian mercenary at the devasted Donetsk airport in Donbas, Ukraine (Image: LB.ua)
  • Devastation at Donetsk airport caused by the Russian aggression in Donbas, Ukraine (Image: LB.ua)
    Devastation at Donetsk airport caused by the Russian aggression in Donbas, Ukraine (Image: LB.ua)
  • Devastation caused by the Russian aggression in Donbas, Ukraine (Image: Tim Judah | NYRblog)
    Devastation caused by the Russian aggression in Donbas, Ukraine (Image: Tim Judah | NYRblog)
  • Devastation caused by the Russian aggression in Donbas, Ukraine (Image: Tim Judah | NYRblog)
    Devastation caused by the Russian aggression in Donbas, Ukraine (Image: Tim Judah | NYRblog)
  • One of the groups of Russian special forces and mercenaries that started the Russian invasion in Donbas, Ukraine
    One of the groups of Russian special forces and mercenaries that started the Russian invasion in Donbas, Ukraine
  • An armed personnel carrier full of mercenaries from Russia in Donbas, Ukraine (Image: inforesist.org)
    An armed personnel carrier full of mercenaries from Russia in Donbas, Ukraine (Image: inforesist.org)
  • Russian mercenaries in Ukraine
    Russian mercenaries in Donbas, Ukraine
  • A Russian soldier from Buryatia fighting in Donbas
    A Russian soldier from Buryatia fighting in Donbas
  • War in Donbas
    War in Donbas
  • War in Donbas
    War in Donbas
  • War in Donbas
    War in Donbas
  • War in Donbas
    War in Donbas
  • War in Donbas
    War in Donbas
  • A destroyed tank in the Donbas, Ukraine
    A destroyed tank in the Donbas, Ukraine
  • Russian terrorists are deliberately destroying the infrastructure of the Donbas. Destroyed railway bridge over the road Sloviansk-Donetsk-Mariupol
    Russian terrorists are deliberately destroying the infrastructure of the Donbas. Destroyed railway bridge over the road Sloviansk-Donetsk-Mariupol
  • Civilian victims of the Russian aggression in Donbas, Ukraine (Source: https://www.facebook.com/freedonbas)
    Civilian victims of the Russian aggression in Donbas, Ukraine (Source: https://www.facebook.com/freedonbas)
  • Civilian victims of the Russian aggression in Donbas, Ukraine (Source: https://www.facebook.com/freedonbas)
    Civilian victims of the Russian aggression in Donbas, Ukraine (Source: https://www.facebook.com/freedonbas)
  • Remains of Malaysia Airline Flight MH-17
    Remains of Malaysia Airline Flight MH-17
  • Russian mercenaries taking photographs with personal items found among the debris at the crash site of MH17 downed by a Russian BUK surface-to-air missile in Russia-occupied east Ukraine (Image: Dmitry Lovetsky/AP)
    Russian mercenaries taking photographs with personal items found among the debris at the crash site of MH17 downed by a Russian BUK surface-to-air missile in Russia-occupied east Ukraine (Image: Dmitry Lovetsky/AP)
  • Debris at the site of the crash of a Malaysia Airlines flight MH17 with 298 people aboard downed by Russian BUK surface-to-air missile in Russia-occupied east Ukraine, on July 19, 2014. (Image: Alexander KHUDOTEPLY/AFP/Getty Images)
    Debris at the site of the crash of a Malaysia Airlines flight MH17 with 298 people aboard downed by Russian BUK surface-to-air missile in Russia-occupied east Ukraine, on July 19, 2014. (Image: Alexander KHUDOTEPLY/AFP/Getty Images)
  • Russia's "little green men" special forces annexing Ukrainian peninsula of Crimea. February 2014
    Russia's "little green men" special forces annexing Ukrainian peninsula of Crimea. February 2014

Edited by: A. N.

Tags: , , , , , , ,

  • OlenaG

    Anyone that puts any trust in what John “Swift Boat” Kerry says is a fool. This man perjured himself before Congress about alleged war crimes by Americans that NEVER happened !! He divorced his first wife to marry “up” to a richer wife. He was only in Vietnam for 90 days yet earned 5 Purple Hearts…that is one about every 12 days…impossible. And then he makes comments about Islamic attacks in Paris that basically justify the attacks.

    While the author of this article makes some good points he should be reminded Congress is controlled by Republicans now and Obama and Kerry have less than a year to do anything. The U.S. Gov’t goes on Christmas break soon and will not be back until 20 Jan 2016 giving Obama and Kerry about 9 months to do anything fighting a Republican Congress before they become a “Lame Duck” Administration after the Presidential Election.

    • Quartermaster

      I wouldn’t trust the Republicans any further than the Dimocraps. The GOP has been controlled by Neoconservatives for many years, and expecting them to take action based on the welfare of anyone other than themselves is foolish.

  • Dirk Smith

    I still can’t determine if our administration is malicious or just deeply incompetent. The muscovites will be partying all weekend after the hundreds of lies they just spewed out again in the media and with this failed administration. Our failed administration obviously doesn’t understand the criminal element yet in the Kremlin, which will be deadly for many innocents for years to come. The only hope will be a qualified GOP candidate to win the election and reverse Obama/Hillary’s damage.

    • Czech Mate

      or maybe they do understand the criminal element far too well. Only Obama & co. chose the easy “way out” like they’d demonstrated many times before.

      It’s all about “legacy” for the selfish egoist in charge.

  • C_Low

    King O in discussion with Medelev “tell Putin I will have more flexibility after the election”.

    At the time we all here in the states assumed that was in reference to his killing of the BMD shield for the EU based in Poland and Cech republic. We learned it was allot more than that.

    Stay strong over there keep your heads down and hold on Febuary 2017 power transitions and I feel confident we at least will have a repub pres maybe even a conservative leaning america first pres which either way will be good for US the west and our allies the world over. HOLD ON STAY STRONG KEEP YOUR HEADS DOWN.

  • Yoshua Zafoy

    The Minsk 2 Accord negotiated by Merkel and Hollande acknowledged Russia as the winner and Ukraine as the loser… on paper. Ukraine will never accept M2A’s consequence… the Federalization of Ukraine… and never implement it, which means that the conflict will continue and the sanctions against Russia will never be lifted.

    The conflict will continue since that is what the West wants.